Let's take a look at the names of the islands for confirmation. Aigilips means 'devoid of goats; hence, incredibly steep, to the point that not even goats can climb it' or 'goatforsaken', if you want. It seems not to be an island where a lot of people should live.

Aigilips/Krokyleia

Ancient Paleros built out of Krokalia

Coast of Plagia or Krokyleia

Krokali means 'Cobble Stone' in Modern Greek, stones with one or more flat sides. So Krokyleia means 'Place of the Cobble Stones'. In Archaic Greek it means 'Coast' which also is flat and is all around Plagia or Krokyleia.

There is very little arable land on Ithaki or Aigilips, the people of the islands make their money in tourism and seafaring. And as you can see in the diagram Ithaki is scarcely populated until this day (well, 2011 that is), which fits the name Aigilips very well.

So the name Krokyleia fits Plagia also very well,
and so does Aigilips.
The sequence we found seems to be right.

On the peninsula Plagia there is an ancient and abandoned city now known as Ancient Paleros or Palairos. The ruins consists out of big stones with flat sides, which was uncommon in 2000BCE when the city was founded, a good reason to call it 'Flat-sided stones'